You are reading

Astoria man faces life in prison for ‘cold blooded’ murder of young father of five in 2020: DA

Astoria man arraigned on murder and assault charges for a bloody rampage that took the life of a young father of five near this iconic mural in 2020. (Photo by Bill Parry)

May 17, 2023 By Bill Parry

An Astoria man was indicted by a Queens grand jury and criminally charged with murder for the fatal stabbing of a father of five and for allegedly assaulting the victim’s sister in the spring of 2020, according to the Queens District Attorney’s Office.

Nathaniel Johnson, 57, of 12th Street near Welling Court and the Astoria Houses, was arraigned Tuesday before Queens Supreme Court Justice Kenneth Holder on charges of murder in the second degree, attempted murder in the second degree, manslaughter in the first degree, assault in the second degree and criminal possession of a weapon in the fourth degree.

According to the charges, on June 7, 2020, at approximately 6:30 a.m., Johnson’s wife, Tangerina Johnson, summoned him to a convenience store near the intersection of 8th Street and Astoria Boulevard. Approximately 10 minutes before Johnson called her husband, she argued with Romeo Bartley, 37, and his sister Amalia Bartley, 34. When Nathaniel Johnson arrived, the sister was in a bodega withdrawing money from an ATM and her brother stood nearby outside.

Video surveillance footage shows Johnson approach the bodega brandishing a knife as his wife pointed out Bartley. Johnson rushed forward and allegedly plunged the knife into his chest then punched and kicked the victim after he fell to the ground, according to charges. When his sister left the ATM, Johnson punched her multiple times in the face then allegedly stabbed her twice in the back.

Officers from the 114th Precinct responded to a 911 call of an assault in progress in front of the iconic “We are family” mural across from the Astoria Houses. EMS arrived at the crime scene and rushed Bartley to Elmhurst Hospital Center, where he was pronounced dead a short while later due his injuries, which included puncture wounds to the heart and lung. His sister was taken to Mount Sinai Hospital-Queens, where she was treated for her injury and was able to identify the defendant from an array of photos.

Tangerina Johnson was arrested nearly a year later and convicted by a jury of murder in the second degree, attempted murder in the second degree and criminal possession of a weapon. She was sentenced to 18 years to life in prison.

Nathaniel Johnson eluded capture for nearly three years until NYPD detectives with the Regional Fugitive Task Force tracked him down in Boston. He was extradited back to Queens and booked at the 114th Precinct on May 15.

“Ruthless. Cold blooded. Brutal. That is the only way to describe what is seen on the video and what the defendant is alleged to have done to the young father of five children,” Queens District Attorney Melinda Katz said. “The defendant will now be held to account.”

Justice Holder ordered Johnson to return to court on July 12. If convicted, he faces 50 years to life in prison.

email the author: [email protected]
No comments yet

Leave a Comment
Reply to this Comment

All comments are subject to moderation before being posted.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Recent News

Community flocks to Jackson Heights for ‘dragtastic’ Queens Pride

New York City’s second-largest Pride celebration, and the first major Pride event taking place this month, kicked off Sunday, June 4, in Jackson Heights, Queens. The theme: Dragtastic.

“With ‘Dragtastic’ as our theme this year, we are saying to the world that we love drag and all it represents,” former New York City Councilmember and LGBT Caucus Chair Daniel Dromm said in a written statement.

NYPD marks opening of new wellness center at High School for Law Enforcement and Public Safety in Queens

The NYPD OPTIONS program, students, staff and alumni of the High School for Law Enforcement and Public Safety held a ribbon-cutting to mark the opening of the school’s new OPTIONS wellness center. The wellness center will help to enhance the personal and professional development of youths through the activities available at this safe and creative space.

Among those on hand to speak about the meaning and impact of this wellness center were High School for Law Enforcement and Public Safety (HSLEAPS) Principal Laura Van Deren, Office of Speaker Adrienne Adams Deputy Chief of Staff and HSLEAPS alumni Tyrell Hankerson, Queens South High Schools Deputy Superintendent Namita Dwarka, New York City Police Foundation Executive Director Greg Roberts, NYPD Deputy Commissioner of Community Affairs Mark Stewart and Police Officer and HSLEAPS alumni Terome Parham.

Ridgewood community group discusses local concerns, welcomes Civil Court candidate Sandra Pérez

The Ridgewood Property Owners and Civic Association kicked off the start of the month with a full meeting inside the basement of the Ridgewood Presbyterian Church, on 59-14 70th Ave., in Ridgewood, on Thursday, June 1. 

More than 50 guests, including the civic association’s board, occupied the intimate space and voiced a number of community concerns, including poor parking situations, rat infestations, improper garbage disposal, and bad landlords. 

Queens nurse relocates medical office to Forest Hills, hopes to inspire others to open their own practice

Stephanie M. Khan Family Practice in Forest Hills celebrated the opening of its new office at 110-78 Queens Blvd. with a ribbon-cutting ceremony last week.

Originally from Howard Beach, Stephanie Khan first started working in Forest Hills as a nurse practitioner during the COVID-19 pandemic in early 2020. During this time, Khan quickly became a popular presence in the community, offering home care services and vaccines to older adults in the area. 

Flushing native Jon Favreau receives honorary doctorate at Queens College 99th commencement ceremony

Flushing native and actor-director Jon Favreau received an honorary doctorate of fine arts at the Queens College 99th commencement ceremony on Thursday, June 1. 

Favreau attended Queens College from 1984 to 1987. His work in films such as “Elf,” “Zathura,” “Iron Man,” “Cowboys and Aliens,” “Chef,” “The Jungle Book” and “The Lion King” is known around the world. He is a key industry influencer through the Marvel Cinematic Universe. 

Queens lawmaker introduces bill in Congress to make Diwali a federal holiday

U.S. Rep. Grace Meng on May 26 announced the introduction of her bill in Congress to declare Diwali a federal holiday. 

Under Meng’s legislation, the Diwali Day Act, the Festival of Lights would become the 12th federally recognized holiday in the United States. Establishing a federal holiday for Diwali, and the day off it would provide, would allow families and friends to celebrate together, and demonstrate that the government values the diverse cultural makeup of the nation.

Long Island firm selected to build construction support facility at JFK Airport to lessen impact on neighbors in southeast Queens

Southeast Queens residents will be chanting “Lets Go Mets” as construction ramps up on the $19 billion JFK transformation project and it will have nothing to do with baseball. The Port Authority on June 1 announced that a Long Island company, the Melville-based Modern Efficient Transport and Supply LLC (METS), has been selected to build and operate an on-airport construction support facility to reduce the impact on neighboring communities over the next several years.

“Not only are we transforming JFK International into the kind of world-class global gateway that our region deserves, but we are doing it in a way that will create the least disruption to communities near the airport,” Port Authority Chairman Kevin O’Toole said. “Innovative strategies like the construction support facility at JFK Airport will eliminate thousands of truck trips from local streets every year, honoring our commitment to build a great airport that will benefit the community and the region.”