You are reading

Brooklyn Diocese Slaps Cuomo With a Lawsuit for Restricting Church Capacity in COVID Hotspots

Our Lady Queen of Martyrs Forest Hills is in an orange zone, where the number of parishioners in church at one time is limited to 25 people or 33 percent capacity (Wikimedia Commons)

Oct. 9, 2020 By Allie Griffin

The Diocese of Brooklyn — which also covers Queens — has slapped Governor Andrew Cuomo and the State of New York with a lawsuit for allegedly violating its First Amendment right to practice religion.

The Diocese filed the lawsuit Thursday in Brooklyn federal court in response to Cuomo’s order restricting the capacity at houses of worship in the parts of Queens and Brooklyn that are seeing an uptick in COVID-19 cases.

Under the order, houses of worship are limited to serve 25 percent capacity or 10 people maximum in state-issued red zones and 33 percent capacity or 25 people maximum in orange zones.

The restrictions, which also closed down religious and public schools in the red and orange zones, went into effect Thursday.

The Diocese argues that Catholic Churches throughout Brooklyn and Queens have had no significant COVID-19 cases and has played “an inconsequential role” in the COVID-19 spikes. Despite this, the state “arbitrarily” reduced capacities at churches, Diocese leaders say.

“The executive orders this week have left us with no other option than to go to court,” said Nicholas DiMarzio, Bishop of Brooklyn.

He said the restrictions impede Catholics’ right to worship.

DiMarzio also said that many churches within the Diocese have the size necessary to safely accommodate worshippers following the six feet social distancing protocols.

The Diocese has spent time, money and energy to implement all the COVID-19 regulations to keep parishioners in Queens and Brooklyn safe from the virus, he added.

The attorney representing the Diocese said the state restrictions deny Catholics their most fundamental right. The lawsuit asks the court to block the state order as applied to Diocese churches.

“This religious community will be denied its most fundamental right — the free exercise of religion — for no legitimate reason whatsoever,” attorney Randy Mastro said. “That’s why we’ve gone to court — to prevent this injustice from occurring.”

An Orthodox Jewish organization has also sued Cuomo over the capacity restrictions for synagogues, according to the New York Post.

The restrictions affect multiple Catholic churches in Queens hotspots. Bishop DiMarzio said the restrictions are disrespectful to Catholics in the area.

“We vehemently disagree with the capacity limits being placed on us,” he said. “They are disrespectful to Catholics who have only been abiding by the rules. We do not agree with such limitations because they completely disregard the fact that our safety protocols have worked.”

Queens Catholic Churches in a red zone, where they are limited to 10 people or 25 percent capacity include:

Our Lady of the Angelus Parish, located at 63-63 98th St. in Rego Park

Queen of Peace Parish, located at 141-36 77th Rd. in Kew Gardens Hills

St. Mary’s Star of the Sea and St. Gertrude Parish, located at 19-20 New Haven Ave. in Far Rockaway

Queens Catholic Churches in an orange zone, where they are limited to 25 people or 33 percent capacity include:

Our Lady Queen of Martyrs Parish, located at 110-06 Queens Blvd. in Forest Hills

St. Nicholas of Tolentine Parish, located at 150-75 Goethals Ave. in Kew Gardens Hills

Churches and other houses of worship in yellow zones are restricted to 50 percent capacity levels.

COVID-19 Cluster zones (COVID-19 Zone Finder)

email the author: news@queenspost.com

5 Comments

Click for Comments 
Tired of Religion Crap.

Obey the law and stop spreading covid. Tired of all these religious people. Whatever you believe in you can do at home until there’s a vaccine. If you want to open these places and then get sick I hope THE CHURCH will take care of you and don’t expect to go to a hospital and have a health care person keep putting their lives on the line for STUPIDITY. All these places is want is your $$$$$ anyway. WHEN you get sick let’s see how they help you. THINK people, get real and STAY HOME.

4
3
Reply
Jon

Governor Cuomo must be held criminally responsible for 6.000 plus New York City nursing home deaths. On March 25th, Cuomo signed an order forcing area hospital covid patients to be sent to local area nursing homes where the virus quickly spread. The result of the Governor’s signed order, thousands of nursing home patients died of the corona virus.

1
2
Reply
Henry

Too bad the RC Church was this fast in acting on religious men who take advantage of minors. This is such a BS act. I never knew that one had to be in church to express their religiosity or to pray to their God.

4
1
Reply
Leo

Why do religions and religious leaders think they don’t have to follow the law. Capacity laws exist, and they followed them before the pandemic. During the pandemic, there is a special reason for reducing capacity. It has nothing to do with practicing your religion. Nobody is telling them they can’t practice their religion; they can practice outside; they can tele-religion if they want. Where do these people live? Mars? These region leaders are selfish, and their churches ought to oust them.

4
1
Reply

Leave a Comment
Reply to this Comment

All comments are subject to moderation before being posted.


The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Recent News

Can Queens’ food scene thrive with both trucks and restaurants?

Aug. 19, 2025 By Jessica Militello

In Jackson Heights at 4 p.m. on a Thursday afternoon, Roosevelt Avenue is buzzing with energy as commuters file in and out of subway cars and onto the street and cars and trucks grapple to get down the busy road. The street is filled with rows of shops and restaurants, along with food carts, street vendors and food trucks along the avenue. The almost-but-not-quite the weekend lag leaves hungry commuters faced with another choice to make throughout their day and the array of food truck options in busy areas like Jackson Heights offers customers convenience and delicious food without breaking the bank, two features that can feel vital, particularly with rising costs of living and pressure from inflation.

NYC Mayor’s Race: New poll shows Mamdani comfortably ahead, but without majority, in 5-way race

Aug. 19, 2025 By Ethan Stark-Miller

The poll of 1,376 likely New York City voters, taken on Aug. 11, shows Mamdani leading the five-way race with nearly 42% of the vote. He is followed by independent former Gov. Andrew Cuomo (23.4%), Republican nominee Curtis Sliwa (16.5%), independent incumbent Mayor Eric Adams (8.8%), and independent attorney Jim Walden (1.4%). The other 7.9% remain undecided.

Exclusive | NYCT honcho shares news of Phase 2 of Queens Bus Network Redesign

Aug. 19, 2025 By Athena Dawson

The MTA has relaunched its Customer Ambassador Program on Monday, Aug 18, continuing the largest customer outreach program in the transit agency’s history. QNS spoke exclusively with acting NYCT Senior Vice President of Buses Chris Pangilinan outside of the Jackson Heights/74 St-Broadway subway station about the second phase of the outreach program and the Queens Bus Network Redesign. 

Lithium-ion battery sparked Murray Hill house fire on Sunday evening: FDNY

FDNY fire marshals have determined that a Murray Hill house fire was caused by a lithium-ion battery on Sunday evening.

The FDNY responded to a report of a basement fire at 164-18 Pidgeon Meadow Rd., just before 7:30 p.m., where firefighters discovered approximately 100 lithium-ion batteries burning in the cellar. The property owner was operating an illegal lithium-ion battery repair business inside the home, and multiple micro-mobility devices and lithium-ion batteries were found in various states of disassembly and disrepair.

South Jamaica man murdered in broad daylight a few doors away from his home: NYPD

A South Jamaica man was stabbed to death in front of his neighbor’s home just down the block from his own house near Baisley Pond Park in broad daylight during the afternoon of Saturday, Aug. 16.

Police from the 113th Precinct in Jamaica responded to a 911 call of a man stabbed in front of 150-16 119th Ave. at 4:10 p.m. Upon arrival, the officers found the 43-year-old victim lying at the curb with a stab wound to his chest. EMS responded to the location and rushed him to Jamaica Hospital Medical Center, where he was listed in critical condition. He succumbed to his injuries and was pronounced dead a short while later, police said.